Difference between revisions of "Talk:List of lonelygirl15 videos/Season 3"

From LGPedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(Section Titles)
("Fighting Back"?: claiming my own comment)
Line 29: Line 29:
  
 
=="Fighting Back"?==
 
=="Fighting Back"?==
As much as I beleive the Trio are taking a more active role, I hardly consider the videos from "Resuing Daniel" onward to be "fighting back," with the exception of Jonas trying to take out that Watcher.  Anyone else agree that this currect Chapter name is a tad inaccurate and should be changed to something similar to "Retreat" -- I mean, come on, they ran to the bloody mountains!
+
As much as I beleive the Trio are taking a more active role, I hardly consider the videos from "Resuing Daniel" onward to be "fighting back," with the exception of Jonas trying to take out that Watcher.  Anyone else agree that this currect Chapter name is a tad inaccurate and should be changed to something similar to "Retreat" -- I mean, come on, they ran to the bloody mountains! --[[User:Phoenician|Phoenician]]
 
:We moved into a new story arc, and clearly the whole thing with Daniel's kidnapping is over (although I don't doubt it will be revisited) so I thought there ought to be a new section. These section names are certqainly not by any means set in stone, it's just when I put it there, there had been a lot of talk about actively fighting the Order, and Jonas assaulted that Watcher... I don't like "retreat", but unless the next video or two goes back to the tone of [[Valentine's Day Massacre]] and [[Watch This!]], probably ''something'' else would be better than what is presently there.--[[User:Brucker|Brucker]] 10:51, 21 February 2007 (CST)
 
:We moved into a new story arc, and clearly the whole thing with Daniel's kidnapping is over (although I don't doubt it will be revisited) so I thought there ought to be a new section. These section names are certqainly not by any means set in stone, it's just when I put it there, there had been a lot of talk about actively fighting the Order, and Jonas assaulted that Watcher... I don't like "retreat", but unless the next video or two goes back to the tone of [[Valentine's Day Massacre]] and [[Watch This!]], probably ''something'' else would be better than what is presently there.--[[User:Brucker|Brucker]] 10:51, 21 February 2007 (CST)
::At least I'm not alone in my thoughts.  Again, "Retreat" was just a suggestion, and a pretty vague one at that. Hopefully the next vids (like "Jonas Sucks") will help clarify this new arc.
+
::At least I'm not alone in my thoughts.  Again, "Retreat" was just a suggestion, and a pretty vague one at that. Hopefully the next vids (like "Jonas Sucks") will help clarify this new arc. --[[User:Phoenician|Phoenician]]
  
 
== Ordering of OpAphid videos ==
 
== Ordering of OpAphid videos ==

Revision as of 05:09, 9 March 2007

Style?

Now that we're using this as the official list instead of the front page, does anyone think this needs a bit of "sprucing up"? --Brucker 18:34, 4 January 2007 (CST)

Yeah, definitely need to do something. We need to spruce up a handful of pages that the new Main Page links to. If nothing else we need a table of contents. This could also be another place to use template:init. It always bugged me that you couldn't tell from the list whose blogs were whose.--JayHenry 19:01, 4 January 2007 (CST)
That would be a good idea. Maybe also a very short decription and/or the date? --Brucker 10:58, 5 January 2007 (CST)

photo montage

What do y'all think? --Brucker 15:09, 11 January 2007 (CST)

Do you mean to literally make a gallery out of the images from the videos?--JayHenry 15:14, 11 January 2007 (CST)
Oh, I'm so dumb. You already did. I like it. I think we need to add an index at the top as well, breaking the videos into time-periods of 20-30 videos.--JayHenry 15:16, 11 January 2007 (CST)
I gave it a try and figured out how to format it, but I'm not really happy on the headings and time periods I chose, maybe you'd like to give it a shot?--Brucker 16:22, 11 January 2007 (CST)
I like the photo montage. It's good for reliving some notable moments in the Breeniverse. Nice work! OwenIsCool 00:55, 14 January 2007 (CST)

and nauseam

LOL!! "Bree & Daniel's relationship and nauseam" just made me chortle. Perhaps that heading is more Latin than the average LG fan can handle these days?--JayHenry 16:40, 23 January 2007 (CST)

Sigh... indeed. ~ Jbshryne 17:21, 23 January 2007 (CST)

Previous/Next Video Links

Should the previous and next video links on the video pages include every video listed on this page? For example, right now the 'next' video in Silent Treatment is An Awkward Silence, which skips Bored At Home. I know this resulted from videos being confirmed canon and added to the list later, but should all of the links be updated to reflect the list we have now? Also, what about the OpAphid videos which are now canon? Is it ok to change the links on those pages too? Thanks.--Jonpro 13:14, 11 February 2007 (CST)

There was some talk about what to do on Talk:Miss Me? when OpAphid got merged. It looks like we decided leave well enough alone for now. You're right that the current "system" leaves out certain videos if you just keep clicking next, but I think what we can do for now is make sure that there are Notes indicating skipped videos whenever it happens (eg, The next video in the series is Bored At Home from Jonas, but at the time of its release he was not a confirmed character). Sure, some less-observant folks might miss it, but I guess it would help. I'm with you in that maybe eventually it will make sense to merge everything, I'm just not sure what would be the best way to do it. OwenIsCool 19:13, 11 February 2007 (CST)
My intention is to find time on Monday to add optional fields on the template for next and previous videos chronolgically. --Brucker 22:00, 11 February 2007 (CST)

"Fighting Back"?

As much as I beleive the Trio are taking a more active role, I hardly consider the videos from "Resuing Daniel" onward to be "fighting back," with the exception of Jonas trying to take out that Watcher. Anyone else agree that this currect Chapter name is a tad inaccurate and should be changed to something similar to "Retreat" -- I mean, come on, they ran to the bloody mountains! --Phoenician

We moved into a new story arc, and clearly the whole thing with Daniel's kidnapping is over (although I don't doubt it will be revisited) so I thought there ought to be a new section. These section names are certqainly not by any means set in stone, it's just when I put it there, there had been a lot of talk about actively fighting the Order, and Jonas assaulted that Watcher... I don't like "retreat", but unless the next video or two goes back to the tone of Valentine's Day Massacre and Watch This!, probably something else would be better than what is presently there.--Brucker 10:51, 21 February 2007 (CST)
At least I'm not alone in my thoughts. Again, "Retreat" was just a suggestion, and a pretty vague one at that. Hopefully the next vids (like "Jonas Sucks") will help clarify this new arc. --Phoenician

Ordering of OpAphid videos

Hey i was wondering about the "List of lonelygirl15 video" page. because certain videos are not in the order that they should be in. they are being put in the order of the posting date on youtube and i think that they should be organized in a way so its more understandable. i dont think that the dates matter as much. like these video titles;

Which Side Are You On? (Keep This In Mind) [The Op video should be after the video by bree; I Listened To Daniel LG, Because the which side are you on video is under video 54# Where's Daniel? and i dont think it has any reference to that episode.

Feel free to correct me if im wrong but i think some of these videos are listed completly out of the order they should be in.

- Michiev

Hi Michiev,
Thanks for letting me know that the current order isn't intuitive. My understanding is that the OpAphid videos are put into that list depending on the numbering assigned to them by the Creators when those episodes were "moved to the left bar" of the lonelygirl15.com website. Where's Daniel? is #54, and Disclosure: Cassie. We Are "They" is #54b. Which Side Are You On? (Keep This In Mind) (the one you said has no reference to Where's Daniel) is #54c.
I hope it's ok with you that I'm copying this discussion to Talk:List of Lonelygirl15 videos so that others may weight in. Personally I'd rather go by the numbers, but I think we should be concerned if those numbers don't make sense to people.
OwenIsCool 15:48, 26 February 2007 (CST)
When I added the Op videos to the list I tried to simply mirror the ordering on the main page. It's possible that I got some of the videos out of order. But in general my philosophy was that if the creators said one video is 45, another is 45a and another 45b then our list should have them in the order 45, 45a, 45b. In other words, I think, this list should reflect the official numbering.--JayHenry 16:49, 26 February 2007 (CST)


I thought that they were in the right order to but then i went to youtube and some of the videos are replies to videos that have already been posted and it makes sense for me to list them in my head that way, The way they are listed now would probably confuse alot of new-comers to the series and especially confuse them about the OpAphid videos.

If you don't know what im talking about, go to OpAphids youtube video list and see what certain videos are responding to.

--Michiev 23:41, 1 March 2007 (CST)

Section Titles

do you think that some of the titles for the different sections should be renamed. i mean early videos isn't exactly a good title for that section, im just wondering

Suggestions are certainly welcome, and if a better one is given, I'm sure everyone will be happy to adopt it. --Brucker 11:37, 28 February 2007 (CST)
I'm liking the new titles . . . though I'm an old fan of "One-worders," these are satisfactory!