Lonelygirl15

Maccaboy17 · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 2:03 pm Post subject:

ok people i've notied that alot of people are going down the line of bree and Jonas being siblings as a result of the revelation of bree's parents not being her natural parents (my assumption being this i some kind of practice fo the order by placing the 'selected' children in the hands of thir best families)

but my simple question is why do we assume that it must be jonas when i could just as easily be daniel?

the answer to this is i guess that its because we are all so keen to see Bree and Daniel together

or is it just because we have assumed that Jonas is more likely because of the larger age gap between Bree and Jonas (2 years i think as apposed to 1 and a bit with Daniel)

but i have to admit that as soon as i heard her say that they were not her natual parent that i instantly thought of Jonas to

but if bree does in fact have a sibling isnt it possible that it it is infact 'Brother' which kind of makes more sense as both are in the orderand that makes more sense than one in and out as the Jonas theory would suggest
_________________
God is not on the side of the big battalions but on the finest shots

Killthesmiley · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 2:08 pm Post subject:

this is what stood out to me

girlAnachronism · Enthusiastic Fan Joined: 06 Dec 2006 Posts: 483

Whew! That was quite an answer to supply, especially just out of the blue. "My parents aren't my real parents"

I don't think that this means she is actually related to Daniel, Jonas, Gemma, Brother, Oppy,Tachy, etc. I think it could be indicative that she has some special [genetic?] condition that made her desirable to the Order. Hence, they placed her under the care of her foster 'parents'.

I really don't think her biological parents should be too important to the story, though. I think that the revelation helped distance Bree from her mum, though.

It would be interesting to learn what Bree's father had to say on the subject of her mother. Could they still be married? Would it be a Giver-like scenario where couples are brought together for the sole purpose of raising kids? I can't wait for the next video!

joygasm · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 2:17 pm Post subject:

EEVEE · Lonely Fan Joined: 21 Dec 2006 Posts: 243

CriticalThinking · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 2:45 pm Post subject:

I feel really bad for Bree. I couldn't imagine how it feels to know that your parents aren't your real parents. Especially in Bree's current situation- she has so much coming at her at once.

joygasm · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 2:47 pm Post subject:

Lord Balto · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 3:14 pm Post subject:

Joyleaf · Casual Observer Joined: 02 Jan 2007 Posts: 27

I was the original poster mentioning the ten year gap, as part of my skepticicsm about the sibling situation--exactly because of this. My mom loved me and my siblings ferociously from the moment each of us were born, and if anyone had taken any of us, she would have hunted them down from square one. Just as you say.

From square one. If a parent was fighting from the very first day, it would surely not take the Order ten years to deal with that. Surely a parent that was persistant in investigation would be offed before they were allowed to even think about the Order.

I mean, by the time they put the evidence together to even point at who took their kids, they've seen and done too much. I get the feeling the Order is more into preventative measures than relative freedom. I think those parents who made a peep about their missing kids would be dealt with pretty harshly, and fast.

Ten years seems like a lot of slop for a secret organization.

But about Jonas...

On the flip side, we know nothing of Jonas's background. And he says certain things that indicate he knows a lot more than he lets on. I think he was cued into finding Bree by something other than her popularity on YouTube.

--He mentions in his first video he's not good with structure. This reminded me a good bit of Tachyon's messages that kept reiterating "having too much order" in her life.

--The way his pop culture references line up with those in Tachyon messages and puzzles.

--He questioned Daniel about Bree's dad, which is pretty strange--I mean, if he watched all of Bree and Daniel's saga, surely he would trust Daniel to recognize a man he had repeatedly gotten into verbal tiffs with.

I think he either recognized Bree's dad as someone else, or he knows Bree's dad to be someone else. Either that or it's a weirdo coincedence.

--I think it's significant to think about what also might have made Jonas confident that he could give Bree and Daniel a happy home when they were on the run. They were being followed, bugged, rooms ransacked, etc.; unless he has a magic disappearing house in the clouds, I think our options are that his home was a) a trap to walk into, or b) a safe haven for reasons we don't understand, like maybe because he's special.

Maybe the sibling thing pans out, or maybe its a red herring.

Joyleaf · Casual Observer Joined: 02 Jan 2007 Posts: 27

spaciegirlreturn · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 3:35 pm Post subject:

CriticalThinking · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 3:37 pm Post subject:

Hmmm... Hamsters.. don't they run scientific tests on hamsters? Maybe that is the nickname for Bree- the "codename", if you will.

girlAnachronism · Enthusiastic Fan Joined: 06 Dec 2006 Posts: 483

They are usually refered to as 'lab rats' or 'guinea pigs' I don't recall people calling a test animal a 'hamster'. Then again, I'm not great at science.

autumneternal · Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 3:46 pm Post subject:

Does anyone remember the video which she snuck out, (0032 - I'm Going to the Party!) and her father was absolutely furious at her and put her on house arrest for doing so, (0033 - House Arrest)? Those two videos, particularly House Arrest seem more significant now. Her father was furious that she put herself outside and in possible danger of being caught by the Order, or possibly in danger of harming herself before completing the ceremony.