Lonelygirl15

smacko · Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2007 4:26 am Post subject: A mixed review is a good review

FWIW, here are my thoughts. First of all, I think Taylor "fits" a lot of the expectations The Creators have put forth. Primarily the quality of filming, editing, lighting, etc...

As for how "likable" she is, I've noticed that the forums seem to show "mixed" reviews of her personality, acting ability, and likability. While all the other "New Girls" seem to have a greater majority of negative posts, often referencing the wrong age, bad lighting, bad acting, inconsistent editing, etc...

To me, a mixed review is a good review, because it provides more for the fanbase to discuss. Whereas a bad review is just that - bad.

Also, there's enough intrigue surrounding her character that I see a lot of possibilities for character development. As always, The Creators will likely take baby-steps, analyze the viewer response, and create the show we want to see.

I just hope we all want to see the same thing... Wink

That all being said, I don't think she could ever replace Bree, but I do see her being a fresh addition to the ever-thinning story line.
_________________
~ §macko ~

Hats off and applause to rogues and revolution!

rupaZer0 · Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2007 5:29 am Post subject:

I liked the new video a bit more. There was almost some proper emotion in it as opposed to performing. And I'm starting to appreciate the subtle things she incorporates into the story, like the thing about her Mum acting kind of outspoken and arrogant - sound familiar? Plus I'm keen to find out what the deal is with her sister. Hopefully she'll stop talking about soccer at some point.
_________________
Cut scene to BDJ in a lubed-up cuddlefest.

smacko · Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2007 5:32 am Post subject:

ladysolitary85 · Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2007 7:15 am Post subject:

First of all, I adore Taylor for 2 reasons: She's original, trying to be least like Bree (come on, wouldn't it be nice if we had our new girl be not as naive as Bree was?), and she reminds me of how fun it was being a kid in high school. She may be over-acting but not too dramatically.

Now as far as her "sister" goes, I think its either Cassie(the way she posed as her sister and the note on her wall), or even Jules (god no). Either way, I think we're all going to be surprised.

I will cry if Jules does play the role over Taylor though...
_________________
http://www.myspace.com/codenameladysolitary

Lurker · Guest

I thought I'd already posted in this thread. I liked this video. She worked some interesting information in around her soccer tale, and I thought she was pretty funny when she was copying her sister.

Anyone else think of hymnofone/Cassandra could totally be her sister?

nowherepixie · Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2007 6:13 pm Post subject:

I did like this more than her first one, I actually cared a bit more about what she had to say this time.

I want to see her sister! Sounds just like me as a teenager Razz

I even had a door a bit like that *cringes* though I didn't write Sylvia Plath quotes on it. Those were reserved for my notebooks...

*sigh*

I'm glad I'm not a teenager anymore! Razz

Jester · Lonely Fan Joined: 03 Apr 2007 Posts: 128

Dude. I really like Taylor. Even though Alessandra is my favorite, if I can't have her, I will totally go for Tayler.

Anything but Jules, and that other chick that I strongly disliked <_<.
_________________

onsweetavenue · Enthusiastic Fan Joined: 03 Jan 2007 Posts: 324

The things I like about Taylor are - the video quality is so much better than the others, and the acting in my opinion, is pretty fair. I'm not an expert on acting but I can tell you she has my attention.

I like that she's a little less naive than Bree. And I think she's interesting.

triumphanddisaster · Suspiciously Absent Joined: 14 Feb 2007 Posts: 3

I'd veto the emo-ranting. Honestly speaking, if we're going to make commentary on the sister, the idea is more mainstream gothic than anything else. Including the use of Sylvia Plath, the stylized crosses, the vampires, and the notably dark, romantic goth literature.

Moving on!

Bree wasn't homeschooled until after the kids at school made fun of her, if you remember. It's perfectly possible that most candidates aren't. Moreso, the idea of siblings? Kinda a fan of that. Yet, while we're looking for clues, we should be careful not to be jumping to conclusions. Keep an alert eye, but don't leap at shadows, eh?
_________________
"If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster,
And treat those two imposters just the same..."

"We call this the revolution."

je_sais_cequisetrame · Posted: Sat Apr 21, 2007 11:55 pm Post subject:

There was a dead rose stuck in the ribbon board.

Gemma had a dead rose.

Then she was revealed to be all evil and then (in theory) she died.

So, hey, maybe we don't have to watch these for much longer? Smile

Hehe.

No, but I thought the dead rose was sort of significant when I saw it because so many people hopped over that with Gemma as it being sort of a sign of her sneakiness or whatever word that is I'm looking for.

Though it did technically belong to her sister, but whatever, I still thought it was sort of significant. In some manner, lol.
_________________
O_O The Hymn of One is Fun. The Hymn of One is Fun. The Hymn of One is Fun. O_O

pimp monkette · Casual Observer Joined: 01 Dec 2006 Posts: 58

Taylor is most definitely my favorite. She's really good with the camera and her story is interesting. She doesn't jump right to the chase like the other girls. She gets us interested with her life first.
_________________
I vote the newgirl be itskassie.

kellylen · Posted: Sun Apr 22, 2007 11:02 pm Post subject:

ok i really hated taylor at first but in this video she totally ROCKED.

i want to know more about her sister Very Happy

_________________
-Kelly

voyboy · Posted: Mon Apr 23, 2007 3:53 am Post subject:

I have said in an earlier post that Taylor isnt the new girl. She cant be. She said shes a die hard lonelygirl15 fan. So she knows her whole story.
She may be a new part of the series for sure but not "the new girl"
_________________
Dreams from the Breenaverse
http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=90CB4AF3668E4366

NikkiBowerReport · Lonely Fan Joined: 30 Oct 2006 Posts: 223

Just found this on myspace. Is this Taylor aka "soccerstar"? So far I don't see anything suspicious - except for an unnatural love for soccer.

http://www.myspace.com/soccerstar_4ever
_________________
Deep Throat: It leads everywhere. Get out your notebook. There's more.

je_sais_cequisetrame · Posted: Mon Apr 23, 2007 10:21 pm Post subject:

Nikki B, you're great, hehe.

Look at her pics -- the middle one is most definately from a portfolio of some sort, unless a girl who usually wears a soccer jersey normally gets dressed up with make-up and cute clothes for poses like that?

I doubt it, lol. But, that sort of solidifies the idea that she's a legitimate actor. I dunno if anyone still doubted it though. O_o
_________________
O_O The Hymn of One is Fun. The Hymn of One is Fun. The Hymn of One is Fun. O_O