Difference between revisions of "Talk:Jonas"
(In defense of Jonas)
|Line 17:||Line 17:|
Revision as of 02:30, 7 March 2007
list of joans's videos: why do we just have his pre-canon videos? i think we should add all of his videos.--Skeeta 00:19, 12 December 2006 (CST)
let's have a section about how people suspected he was canon.--Skeeta 00:20, 12 December 2006 (CST)
Jonas's vids: can't we transcription of his vids like we do with bree and the rest? just because he's not officially canon doesn't mean we can't pay as much attention to his vids.
- It just takes someone to do the hard work. Why don't u think about getting the ball rolling:)--modelmotion 23:45, 25 November 2006 (CST)
I don't really know how to start an individual page.
some people talked about why bree would show a poster for that movie about that lifeguard (the title slips my mind right now and i have a feeling i'll kick myself when it slips back in) and it sorta tells jonas' story; someone helping people AT SEA!! other people have commented that it might have to do with one of bree's parents now being gone, but i say it refers to both Jonas' parents being gone.
where is the poster ur talking about... at the movie theater? oh, do you mean the ashton kutcher movie, the guardian i think?
The Book Jonas Found
Do you think a section in Jonas' page devoted to the book/transcript he found about the Order should made? It seems like it could lead to something important to the story. Malan89 20:30, 6 March 2007 (CST)
does anyone think his parents may have been kidnapped/killed by the cult? i wouldn't put it past the creators... or is that too much of a stretch?
- Anything is possible. I wish we knew more about the 140th line of latitude. A lot of unknowns and not many concrete answers.--modelmotion 19:39, 26 November 2006 (CST)
Page Needs Rewritten
I am positive that Jonas is not canon now, because of the following reasons. One, Jonas' video, "Trust Issues" was on the lonelygirl15.com homepage and was counted as an episode. Two, Bree acknowledged Jonas' video "Happy Thanksgiving" in her video "Thanksgiving". Finally, Daniel just made a whole video about Bree, the main character, thinking about going to Jonas' house, in the video "Jonas?" Jonas is not canon, I am sure of that. This page makes it sound like Jonas IS canon, when in fact, he is not. This page needs a total rewrite because Jonas is now an official character. Maybe I will get to work on. --silverBULLET (x3) 17:40, 30 November 2006 (CST)
First three videos
Are Jonas's first three videos considered canon, since Jonas himself is canon? I ask for the purposes of the list of YouTube tags and the official list of LG15 videos.--Jonpro 12:45, 10 December 2006 (CST)
- Yes. --Treefunk 12:47, 10 December 2006 (CST)
Honestly, I haven't read "The Great Gatsby" so there may be something more to it than I am aware, but this seems like a common theme in many stories, including at least one Biblical parable. In the words of Danny Elfman: "When football's over and the beer's gone, tell me where my friends go..." --Brucker 12:26, 6 February 2007 (CST)
- I've read the Great Gatsby. In fact the Jay in my name is taken from Jay Gatsby. (As for Henry, if you're interested in Lost Generation American lit, it's from Frederic Henry). And the Jonas-Gatsby connection is a huge stretch. I don't want to spoil Gatsby, because every American should read it, but suffice it to say the situations are almost completely different.--JayHenry 12:43, 6 February 2007 (CST)
In defense of Jonas
I don't know if people think any of my speculation should go here or on the plot holes page, but I have a few things to point out.
Jonas is the first person in the official series to point out that Gemma was a member of the Order. It seems to be the case that Bree didn't notice the Tachyon video until Jonas showed it to her and Daniel. If Gemma was truly a member of the Order, as everyone assumes (I'm still only about 90% convinced the case is closed on that matter) why would he want to draw attention to Gemma's deception?
At the time Jonas posted the clip of Gemma and Lucy together, Bree was staying at his house free and clear, with no suspicions on him, and no Daniel around to interfere. Of course, that was only one of several times that Jonas had access to Bree without interference from Daniel, the other two times being when Daniel was off at Pins 'n' Pints (and his subsequent kidnapping).
Furthermore, if the Order wants Daniel out of the way, and Jonas is with them, he did have at least one chance to take care of Daniel without Bree being around to see anything during the last week of December.
My conclusion from this is that either Jonas is not with the Order, or if he is, than my personal theory I have expressed before is true, namely that the Order, while following Bree and Daniel very closely, have no desire to harm them.