Talk:Neutrogena
From LGPedia
joke?
is this some kind of joke? - platypus
- Okay, first of all, I am female, believe it or not. Second of all, why would this be a joke? Read the news sources listed with this article. I don't even get what could possibly be "funny" about this. --Zoey 13:49, 24 June 2007 (CDT)
- umm... get over yourself zoey. - platypus
- Wow okay, that was really uncalled for. I posted a factual and relevant article about something related to LG15 and cited various sources for my work. It was further edited by Milowent. However, you then felt the need to change the topic sentence from "it was announced" to "Zoey thought it would be funny if he said". That's completely bogus. First of all, even if it was a joke, why single me out like that? The majority of the edits were actually made by Milowent. Second of all, there were MULTIPLE links that confirmed what I said, so clearly it wasn't just some "joke". You could have easily asked on the talk page BEFORE making those edits, but instead, you decided to make an edit declaring that I personally thought it would be funny if I made up a rumor to that effect. Furthermore, you decided that I was male, which I just thought added insult to injury, because really, I have never met a male "Zoey". My response to you was not "big-headed" or anything of the sort, so it did not justify a "get over yourself zoey" reply. If you disagree with something I say or you have a question about an article, you can always feel free to POLITELY ask about it or POLITELY disagree, but personally insulting me is unfair and uncalled for. --Zoey 15:00, 25 June 2007 (CDT)
- whatever im not going to entertain this any further. only dorks read history pages and argue about them. i changed it back so once again get over yourself. - platypus
- Again, completely uncalled for. You made an attack on me, then furthered it with petty name-calling. I could argue that "only dorks edit Wikis" to begin with. Or more personally, I could go with "only dorks call themself platypus." But I won't. Because both are uncalled for and untrue. Like I said, I have no problem with you expressing your doubts about the truthfulness of an article, but do it in a respectful way! --Zoey 17:01, 26 June 2007 (CDT)
- whatever im not going to entertain this any further. only dorks read history pages and argue about them. i changed it back so once again get over yourself. - platypus
- Wow okay, that was really uncalled for. I posted a factual and relevant article about something related to LG15 and cited various sources for my work. It was further edited by Milowent. However, you then felt the need to change the topic sentence from "it was announced" to "Zoey thought it would be funny if he said". That's completely bogus. First of all, even if it was a joke, why single me out like that? The majority of the edits were actually made by Milowent. Second of all, there were MULTIPLE links that confirmed what I said, so clearly it wasn't just some "joke". You could have easily asked on the talk page BEFORE making those edits, but instead, you decided to make an edit declaring that I personally thought it would be funny if I made up a rumor to that effect. Furthermore, you decided that I was male, which I just thought added insult to injury, because really, I have never met a male "Zoey". My response to you was not "big-headed" or anything of the sort, so it did not justify a "get over yourself zoey" reply. If you disagree with something I say or you have a question about an article, you can always feel free to POLITELY ask about it or POLITELY disagree, but personally insulting me is unfair and uncalled for. --Zoey 15:00, 25 June 2007 (CDT)
- umm... get over yourself zoey. - platypus
