Difference between revisions of "Talk:The swimming hole"
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
:Modelmotion, would you please read my points in the discussion at [[Talk:Main Page]]. Nobody is saying the ''information'' should be deleted. We are saying that the locations do not need ''separate pages''. We are not removing locations from LGPedia, we are simply organizing them in a way that makes sense. Please continue the discussion at [[Talk:Main Page]] unless you have particular points to add about the Swimming Hole as deserving of its own page.--[[User:JayHenry|JayHenry]] 19:03, 15 November 2006 (PST) | :Modelmotion, would you please read my points in the discussion at [[Talk:Main Page]]. Nobody is saying the ''information'' should be deleted. We are saying that the locations do not need ''separate pages''. We are not removing locations from LGPedia, we are simply organizing them in a way that makes sense. Please continue the discussion at [[Talk:Main Page]] unless you have particular points to add about the Swimming Hole as deserving of its own page.--[[User:JayHenry|JayHenry]] 19:03, 15 November 2006 (PST) | ||
| − | Due to a lack of plot elements that this location provides, as opposed to the [[Swimming!]] video, I believe these photos should be included as thumbnails on the video's page. This article currently offers no useful information, and anything that could be added is already covered under the topics of [[Cassieiswatching]] or [[Swimming!]]. I feel that this article warrants deletion. -- [[User:Twjaniak|Twjaniak]] 05:57, 16 November 2006 (PST) | + | |
| + | Due to a lack of plot elements that this location provides, as opposed to the [[Swimming!]] video, I believe these photos should be included as thumbnails on the video's page. This article currently offers no useful information, and anything that could be added is already covered under the topics of [[Cassieiswatching]] or [[Swimming!]]. I feel that this article warrants deletion. Redirects from Swimming Hole could lead to the video's page instead. This is how the such issues are frequently handled on the WIkiPedia. -- [[User:Twjaniak|Twjaniak]] 05:57, 16 November 2006 (PST) | ||
Revision as of 14:02, 16 November 2006
I stongly disagree the notion that location pages should be deleted. Location play a vital role in the plot development and should be included in LGpedia. Further, clues often lie within the nature of the location and hence they provide a focal point for discussions.--modelmotion 18:58, 15 November 2006 (PST)
- Modelmotion, would you please read my points in the discussion at Talk:Main Page. Nobody is saying the information should be deleted. We are saying that the locations do not need separate pages. We are not removing locations from LGPedia, we are simply organizing them in a way that makes sense. Please continue the discussion at Talk:Main Page unless you have particular points to add about the Swimming Hole as deserving of its own page.--JayHenry 19:03, 15 November 2006 (PST)
Due to a lack of plot elements that this location provides, as opposed to the Swimming! video, I believe these photos should be included as thumbnails on the video's page. This article currently offers no useful information, and anything that could be added is already covered under the topics of Cassieiswatching or Swimming!. I feel that this article warrants deletion. Redirects from Swimming Hole could lead to the video's page instead. This is how the such issues are frequently handled on the WIkiPedia. -- Twjaniak 05:57, 16 November 2006 (PST)
