Difference between revisions of "Talk:GuillotineCalamity"
From LGPedia
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
::Without debate, I am totally against this. --[[User:LordGreystoke422|LordGreystoke422]] 23:45, 2 February 2007 (CST) | ::Without debate, I am totally against this. --[[User:LordGreystoke422|LordGreystoke422]] 23:45, 2 February 2007 (CST) | ||
| + | |||
| + | :::Here, here. Totally against it. It is problematic FEATURING a fanfic. I think we should gather 'round and think of various themes that have run through LG15, whether early on or now. Pages related to those things should be featured, not response videos made by unrelated people. What does that add to our better understanding of lonelygirl15? I mean come on, if you are short of things, try featuring P. Monkey, or Owen, or Thor, to just name three. Each of those are deeply related to LG15 herself and would be of interest. There are other less well known but firmly canonical things which could also fit the bill of appropriateness, but a fanfic with no real cross-over in the lonelygirl world should make it. (Now if it was a fan-fic directly tied into the plot, or one that is obvious comedy, might be a different story.) [[User:HyeMew|HyeMew]] 00:04, 3 February 2007 (CST) | ||
Revision as of 06:04, 3 February 2007
veritas means truth in latin. it's harvard's motto.--Skeeta 18:24, 23 January 2007 (CST)
So...codes into truth? User:Crowcity
|
This article has been nominated as a featured article. Discuss here. |
Ok, so I nominate GC's page because I think it has a fair amount of clarity, cleanliness and is related to LG15, as some of her videos are in response to LG15 videos, and the storyline revolves around a community, just like Bree's. And Like LL's page, let's not try to argue. This is a discussion, not a competitive debate. .--Crowcity
- Without debate, I am totally against this. --LordGreystoke422 23:45, 2 February 2007 (CST)
- Here, here. Totally against it. It is problematic FEATURING a fanfic. I think we should gather 'round and think of various themes that have run through LG15, whether early on or now. Pages related to those things should be featured, not response videos made by unrelated people. What does that add to our better understanding of lonelygirl15? I mean come on, if you are short of things, try featuring P. Monkey, or Owen, or Thor, to just name three. Each of those are deeply related to LG15 herself and would be of interest. There are other less well known but firmly canonical things which could also fit the bill of appropriateness, but a fanfic with no real cross-over in the lonelygirl world should make it. (Now if it was a fan-fic directly tied into the plot, or one that is obvious comedy, might be a different story.) HyeMew 00:04, 3 February 2007 (CST)
